How we score

Every product gets a 0–100 score for what it could do to you. Here’s what goes into it, where the data comes from, and where it falls short.

Not medical advice.Scores describe ingredients and materials. They aren’t a diagnosis, a treatment plan, or a safety certification. Talk to your doctor, pediatrician, or vet about your situation.

The 0–100 score

Crunchy scores personal toxicity: what a product could do to the person using it. Packaging waste, carbon footprint, and reef impact aren’t part of the score.

Here’s how a score comes together:

  1. Find the shelf. We work out what the product is from its full title and label, so a butter isn’t scored like a cooking oil.
  2. Read the label. Ingredients for food and beauty, materials for clothing, furniture, and cookware.
  3. Check each one. Every ingredient or material is matched against our hazard database and given a severity.
  4. Weigh by use. A leave-on lotion counts more than a rinse-off soap. Plastic touching hot food counts more than plastic on a handle.
  5. Combine by rubric. Each shelf has weighted factors. The score is the weighted total, and every factor shows its reasoning in the app.
  • 85–100Excellent
  • 70–84Solid Pick
  • 50–69Some Concerns
  • 30–49Use Caution
  • 0–29Skip This One

Rubrics by shelf

These are the base weights for each shelf. More than 50 specialized rubrics adjust them for specific products, like cookware, sunscreen, toothpaste, mouthwash, formula, pet food, sparkling water, sweeteners, produce, probiotics, and electrolytes.

Food

  • Additives30%
  • Processing level25%
  • Nutritional balance25%
  • Pesticide risk20%

Beauty

  • Endocrine disruptors28%
  • Irritant risk22%
  • Carcinogen screening22%
  • Material safety15%
  • Fragrance13%

Cleaning

  • VOC content25%
  • Skin and respiratory irritants25%
  • Chemical persistence20%
  • Child safety15%
  • Fragrance15%

Baby

  • Ingredient safety37%
  • Heavy metals and contaminants28%
  • Certifications20%
  • Processing level15%

Pets

  • Ingredients47%
  • Recalls28%
  • Nutrition25%

Water

  • Water purity37%
  • Contaminants33%
  • Container30%

Supplements

  • Ingredients40%
  • Certifications30%
  • Purity testing30%

Clothing

  • Fabric30%
  • Dyes20%
  • Formaldehyde18%
  • PFAS and waterproofing17%
  • Organic certification15%

Furniture

  • VOC off-gassing30%
  • Flame retardants25%
  • Certification25%
  • Material origin20%

Dishware

  • Lead and cadmium30%
  • Material safety25%
  • Heat resistance15%
  • Coating durability15%
  • Certification15%

Kitchen

  • Plastic-to-food contact25%
  • Chemical safety25%
  • Heat safety20%
  • Material grade15%
  • Longevity15%

Toys

  • Lead and heavy metals30%
  • Phthalates25%
  • Choking hazard15%
  • CPSC compliance15%
  • Age fit15%

Sources

Hazard rules come from published classifications and research, not influencer opinion:

  • International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classifications
  • EU regulations, including REACH, the cosmetics ingredient annexes, and food additive decisions
  • US FDA and EPA guidance and limits
  • California Proposition 65
  • US Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) rules for children’s products
  • Environmental Working Group (EWG) databases, used as one input among several
  • Peer-reviewed toxicology studies

Ingredient lists come from Open Food Facts, brand websites, and the labels you scan. When a product isn’t on file, we use AI to read its current label. We only score it when the exact formula can be confirmed. If it can’t, you’ll see that we don’t have enough data yet.

Personal flags

Personal flags sit on top of the score. They call out what matters to your household, like an allergen, synthetic folate for MTHFR, or an ingredient to watch during pregnancy. The same product can carry a flag for you and not for someone else.

Pet products only show your pets’ watch-lists, never the people in your household. Your profile is stored only on your iPhone. Read more in our consumer health data policy.

Limits

  • Scores reflect the label we have. Brands change formulas, and store listings can be out of date. Scanning the label in your hand gives the most accurate result.
  • Some ingredients have little research. When data is thin, we say so instead of guessing.
  • Labels don’t always tell the whole story. “Fragrance” and “natural flavor” can stand for many ingredients. We flag what isn’t disclosed.
  • Dose matters. A flagged ingredient in a product you use once a year is different from one you use daily. The score accounts for how a product is used, not for your personal exposure.
  • A score isn’t a safety certification. It’s a summary of what we can verify about the ingredients.

Report a wrong score

Spotted a wrong ingredient list, the wrong product, or a score that looks off? Email corrections@crunchyapproved.com with:

  • The product name and brand
  • A photo of the ingredient label, if you have one
  • What looks wrong

We check every report against the label and fix the data when it’s wrong. Brands are welcome to send updated ingredient lists the same way.

See the score before you buy

Free on iPhone. Every score shows its reasons.